2013-11-20

Kimi no Iru Machi - manga - revisit and expanded review

Kimi no Iru Machi (A Town Where You Live) is an ongoing romance manga from Seo Kouji, who also created the romance manga/anime Suzuka.

    The story beings with first year high school student, Haruto Kirishima, who lives on the countryside outside of Hiroshima, having to deal with a troublesome guest.  Before school starts an unwelcomed guest moves into his families’ house, Yuzuki Eba.  Yuzuki is the daughter of Haruto’s fathers’ childhood friend.  She has decided to move from Tokyo to get away from her family and will be spending her high school career living with Haruto’s family instead.  This situation causes embarrassment with Haruto, who doesn’t want anything to do with the spunky and helpless Yuzuki.  Due to his overwhelming sense of helping others though he can’t leave her to her own devices.  This causes problems as he worries over everyone thinking they are a couple, particularly his love interest Nanami Kanzaki.  Soon though everything smoothes out to some extent and Haruto has some mild success with Nanami.  When he confesses to her she balks and doesn’t give him an answer right away.  By the time she gives him her answer he may already be falling for Yuzuki.  Drama ensues, with a lot of back and forth between the three of them.  Nanami tells Haruto that she can’t be with him as long as he has any feelings for Yuzuki.  Just as Haruto and Yuzuki are about to begin dating for real she decides to move back to Tokyo, unexpectedly.

    At first they agree to a long distance relationship, but misunderstandings during a school trip to Tokyo between all three again causes Yuzuki to cut off all ties with Haruto.  With Yuzuki out of the way Haruto and Nanami are finally able to date.  Before long though, attention is again shifted to Yuzuki as Haruto discovers a note from their last meeting telling him why she has cut off all contact.  He interprets the note as a cry for help and rashly decides to transfer to Tokyo to finish up his high school career.  Nanami reluctantly stops dating him, as she understands his deep seeded love for Yuzuki.  With some trouble In Tokyo Haruto discovers that Yuzuki left him to begin dating a guy she went to middle school with who had a crush on her.  To make matters worse the guy is one of 2 friends Haruto has made since moving to Tokyo, Kyosuke Kazama.  Neither of them knew that Yuzuki and Haruto knew each other and vice-verse.  To make it even more complicated Kyosuke has less than a year to live.  Haruto doesn’t back down however and challenges Kyosuke for Yuzuki’s love.  In the end though, Yuzuki tells Haruto that she doesn’t want anything to do with him, completely disrupting the only reason he moved to Tokyo.

    We then find Haruto as a freshman in college, most of his friends from Hiroshima, Nanami included, decided to move to Tokyo as well to get the whole gang back together.  Haruto has started dating the other person he first made friends with, Asuka Mishima.  With Yuzuki out of the picture for good, Haruto and Asuka’s relationship blossoms, until Yuzuki’s little sister begins to disrupt that union and brings Yuzuki back into the picture.  Haruto must make a choice once and for all who he wants to be with.  Yuzuki, with their long and checkered past, or Asuka, who brings him happiness and support.  With everyone so close now what will his choices mean for his circle of close friends and for his future.

    OK, so I started originally reading this manga when it first came out, back in 2009.  I stopped reading it though, for some hazy reasons.  I decided to pick up the manga again after watching the 13 episode anime that aired in Japan in the summer of 2013.  I think part of the reason I stopped reading it originally was due to much of the story being pure garbage.  I kept forcing myself through the manga to see how it related to the anime and what was changed.  The anime for Kimi no Iru Machi pretty much starts with issues 81 through 142 of the manga, then references previous episodes throughout its 13 episode run.  There are some side characters and story arcs that were not included in the anime, but you pretty much get a play by play.  Once I got to that point I had already ingested 142 issues of the manga so I stuck with it out of just seeing it through.  At the time of this writing I have caught up with the series and am waiting for issues 253 to be released.  I still really don’t like it.

    Haruto is a sack of shit.  It’s hard to really like him when his flaws are his only good points.  He’s inconsistent, flighty and downright disagreeable.  Through the course of the series, which covers so far about 6 or 7 years, he has caused quite a lot of trouble for everyone around him with his half hearted pursuits.  The main woman of his attention, Yuzuki is also quite annoying.  She’s a bit of a brainless princess and has a flat personality.  Aside from these two main characters not being to my liking there is an unnecessary amount of ecchi material in the comic.  There were whole chapters I skipped due to this fact.  It got annoying when every 20 chapters or so all the female characters are going to a bath house…with barely any plot and story development.  But whatever, you gotta make the readers interested right?  Spend that cash?  Just another check mark for the sad state the manga/anime industry in Japan has gone to.

    I like more realism in my romance stories; too many of the plot lines in Kimi Machi are tired, played out and ridiculous.  An example, in one issue Yuzuki brings up the idea of Haruto being concerned about premature ejaculation with all of their friends and thinks it has something to do with his mental health.  Seriously?  What a waste of time…

    Anyways, the manga is really not worth that much investment.  You do get a pretty good idea of everything by watching the 13 episode anime.  If you want to see what happens from there, then start with issue 143 of the manga.  I’m going to keep reading it…I don’t think Kouji can squeeze too much more out of this series and I’ve invested so much time into reading all of it that I should see it out to the end.


No comments: