The fifth edition of the retrospective is here! Over the five submissions so far we have covered 140 titles. For quicker
navigation, here is the home of the first retrospective, then the home of the second retrospective, the home of the third retrospective and the home of the fourth retrospective.
The 100 Girlfriends Who Really Really Really REALLY Love You
Rintaro, after being rejected by 100 girls, prays at a local shrine out of desperation to finally find love. The shrines god grants him that wish, but tells him that a mistake was made at the time of his birth and he will have 100 women fall in love with him. He has to make sure that he loves all of them, or else those he can not love will die prematurely. Undaunted by the prospects and logistics, he surges forward in his new high school life, looking for love in all of the places.
Its hard to tell whether this is a joke, a sad fantasy or a combination of both. The story takes the idea of a dating sim game and bypassing all of the complications with choosing one by choosing all of them equally. Aside from the absurdity of the situation, the crazy rampant fan service and the blithe response to Rintaro's goal, the series is rather amusing. At this time there is only one season and I am not certain I will have any interest in watching the continuation of it when it comes out.
365 Days to the Wedding
Two awkward employees at a travel agency concoct a plan to have a fake marriage in order to avoid being transferred to a branch office opening in Anchorage Alaska. As they struggle to convince themselves that their ruse is working they slowly develop feelings for each other. They are both content living solitary lives and struggle to understand what the other person is really thinking, all while continuing to do more to convince everyone around them they are really a couple.
This is a cute adult office romance that focuses on two socially inept hermits. Knowing they will eventually become a real couple isn't hard to recognize, but the journey is filled with fun moments and some good side stories that give a pretty well fleshed out story, though it did end rather abruptly...still worth the watch.
A Condition Called Love
Hotaru doesn't understand the first thing about romance. When one
of the hottest guys in school, Hananoi asks her to go out with him, she
doesn't know how to respond. His persistence borders on concerning as
he tries to persuade her to give him a chance, feeling she may discover
romance when putting it to the test. Recognizing his persistence she
agrees to a tial run relationship with him, willing to see if anything
sparks for her as they spend time together.
While initially
problematic, particularly with how possessive and dangerous Hananoi was,
the story ended up being a rather sweet tale of burgeoning love. This
was a romance that strayed from many of the more standard character
types. Hotaru is an nontraditional female lead, given her plain and
unassuming persona. She strives to not make any waves around her,
fearing for reprisals. While in elementary school she had a traumatic
fall out with her best friend over misunderstandings about a classmate.
Hananoi though looks like some visual kei guy even though his
personality is that of the loner otaku stalker. There is a fare amount
of drama, enough to over whelm the lighter elements of the story.
Alya Sometimes Hides Her Feelings in Russian
Alisa is a half Japanese, half Russian high school student who harbors hidden feelings for the boy she sits next to in class, Masachika. The carries herself with a stern tsundere-like demeanor and hides her true feelings from him by hitting on him in Russian. Unknown to her, Masachika understands whats she saying, due to spending a lot of time as a young boy playing with a girl of Russian decent. He struggles with what her intentions are when she says things to him or about him in Russian and is hesitant to take anything at face value.
Initially I misunderstood the premise that Masachika did not understand her and worried the plot device would grow weary quickly. The idea that he does understand her adds a satisfying layer of enjoyment out of their interactions. While the story was a lot of fun at first about hald way through the first season its tone shifts in a weird way. Or more precisly it begins to focus on a plot line that consumes more of the stories attention than it should and greatly detracts from the growing closeness of the two main characters.
The Apothecary Diaries
Maomao, the daughter of a lowly apothecary, who grew up hanging out in a brothel, finds herself kidnapped and forced into contracted servitude in the Imperial palace. Her desire to remain inconspicuous is undone by her curiosity and deep knowledge about poison and physiology. She is picked out by the highers eunuch in the rear palace, reserved for the concubines, to work for one of the top four mistresses. Maomao's abilities to resist poison place her in the role of food tester while her intilect and curiosity continues to bring her into the eunuchs favor, among the thick intrigue of palace life.
The romance for this show is very very subdued, almost imperceptible. The show is primarily a mystery series sprinkled with a bit of comedy and drama. Through out all of it there is a very very slow simmering romance between Maomao and the eunuch Jinshi. But...given his attitude and appearance is he really a eunuch? Beyond that, this was a well an interesting story, even if the romance was almost absent. It is a good story in the end with a well crafted pay off and a look to the continuing story were we should see more romance.
Astro Note
Takumi is an out of work chef who replies to a help wanted ad for a promising restaurant. Instead he find the place to be a run down share house. He is about to leave when he hears a commotion and comes to find its manager dangling precariously from the roof. After using him to break her fall, Mira apologizes to him for the misleading help wanted ad. Through the urging of the houses odd borders and his sudden love for the beautiful young woman, Takumi agrees to take the job. Little does he or anyone else know Mira is an alien princess who has come to Earth to find a lost item that will allow her to ascend the thrown for his world and become its queen.
This fantastic original series takes a lot of cue's from Maison Ikkoku with plenty of nods to other classic anime from a variety of genres. This well crafted character driven story shows that sometimes love is all you need to find a purpose in your life. It blends romance, comedy, slice of life, sci-fi and mecha seamlessly into a story that never disappoints.
Blue Box
Taiki, a freshman on the badminton team, has his eyes on a second years student and star of the girls basketball team, Chinatsu. WHen she ends up moving in with his family, so she can continue her fantastic sports career instead of leaving the country with her family, the boy struggles with his sudden proximity to her. Now he has to fret over if he has the courage to tell her how he feels about her.
I should have liked this, given how close it is in theme to my original romance love, Suzuka, but its struggles under the lack of depth in its primary characters. It is nice in that is refuses to fall into the less noble tropes found in shonen love stories but suffers from the lack of personality.
Bottom-Tier Character Tomozaki
Tomozaki is a social outcast gamer nerd who also happens to be the top ranked player in Japan for...essentially Smash Brothers. The second ranked player asks to meet him IRL and hes floored to learn its one of his classes popular girls, Hinami. At first revolted that her nemesis is a loser from school, she decides to turn his obsessive perfectionist approach to the game into a tool to improve his social standing. She presents his life as a game to play and sets goals for him to achieve. Not wanting to shirk the challenge, he faces her tasks head on, willing to improve himself and his lot in life.
The series started out as a boring/rote dating sim with a loser as the MC, but turned into an interesting and enjoyable realistic drama with a wide cast of characters. The characters, while largely one dimensional in their archetypes, did present themselves as an enjoyable cast. While skepticism and experience can lend the viewer to easily recognize the end of the series in terms of partnering, the course of the story does a really good job of putting anything up as a possibility. The characters are more realistic in their mannerisms and inter personal relationships than you would typically find in this style of romance, which added to the enjoyment of the story as it evolved.
Dan Da Dan
Momo is a flashy gyaru who just wants to find a love like the famous strong man actor Takakura Ken. After getting dumped by her good for nothing boyfriend she ends up helping an otaku from being bullied...only because she wants to fight someone. The otaku misunderstands her intentions and an argument ensues. He tries to bridge the gap with her by talking about the occult. He believes in alien invaders and shes the granddaughter of a spirit medium. They change the other to a test of faith with results in the boy being possessed and Momo feeling guilt about it, literally responsible for saving him with awakened psychic abilities. Now they fight a batch of weird forces while they work to remove the curse on a boy...whose name is Takakura Ken.
This is a stealth super natural shonen action series that has a heavy emphasis about the two main characters growing affection for the other. This anime is a pretty good complete package, offering an ever changing story type with amazing art direction by the fantastic Science Saru. While its a good all around package, its also a bit two weird and uncomfortable at some points for newer anime fans,
Days With My Stepsister
Yuta lives an unobtrusive life, focused on being as self reliant as possible. When his father remarries, he gains a step-sister the same age, named Saki. In order to maintain their comfortable patterns in this new arrangement, they agree to not do anything without agreeing to some for of exchange. This leads them living an existence as a business arrangement instead of as a family that can rely on each other without condition. Those constraints begin to break down as their time together grows and Saki in particular struggles with emotions growing for her new brother, who seems to be working on a relationship with an older coworker.
Everyone knows how step-siblings are supposed to behave in anime romances and will be severely disappointed in how this one handles that trope. It doesn't touch it with a 10ft pole. In fact there is barely any romance in this. Instead it is a dry and slow paced drama about two strangers struggling with how to deal with the massive upheaval of their lives. They navigate around each other in a way to not disrupt the wishes of their parents happiness as well as their own perceptions of the others focus and goals. It ended up being a breath of fresh air, even if the tension is as slow as its characters are emotional.
Fruits Basket
Tohru is a hard working orphan, who has been secretly camping in a forested region of a spacious estate. She does not wish to burden her extended family and chooses to live homeless. Her secret is quickly exposed by the residents of the estate, the Souma clan, of which some members she goes to school with. Feeling sorry for the poor girl, she is invited to stay with them instead, in exchange for doing cleaning and cooking. Problems arise with her lodging as the Souma clan has a dark secret that her presence has complicated. The family is incredibly wealth and vast, with some of its members inheriting super natural aspects linked to the 12 zodiac creatures. If they come with in physical contact of someone of the opposite sex it will force them to transform into their zodiac form. As Tohru settles in she fnds herself in the middle of a dangerous power struggle between her new friends and the head of the family.
This is one of those classic romances that is well loved in shojo circles. In 2019 it received an anime remake so I decided to finally watch it. I got through the first 25 or so episodes but had to stop because of how abusive the story turned into. There is so much painful drama and heart ache in the story I couldn't bring myself to continue it, loosing all interest in the stories resolution. I've come to the conclusion that consuming this story is akin to self harm. But, that isn't to say it isn't bad, I just don't have the fortitude for this form of darkness and depression in a romance.

Grandpa and Grandma Turn Young Again
One day while working their farm, an elderly couple discover a gleaming golden apple growing from a tree in their orchard. They decide to share it and in the morning wake to discover their bodies restored to the youth and vigor of their late 20's. Unsure as to whats going on, they decide to take this second chance and make up for the things they were too poor or busy to do when they were newlyweds.
This is a cute and endearing story with a fun super natural aspect to it. The story spends a lot of time focusing on the elderly couple causing waves around them in their youthful forms as well as them trying to tackle modernity. Beyond the story of the couple, there is some depth given to their immediate family, particularly two high school aged grand children. The artwork and character design was a little subpar, but the story was sweet and endearing in the end.
Honey Lemon Soda
Ichimori has no self confidence and freezes when interacting with others in school. A chance encounter with one of the most desired boy in class changes her trajectory in life. He pushes her in his own obtuse manner to build confidence and stop begin negative on herself, protecting her from the trouble around her until she can stand on her own two feet.
In general I didn't like this series given how I perceive the negative connotations of Ichimori and how she works to change herself from timid to confident. It sets a bad precedent for members of the audience who identify with our lead and hope to achieve a similar line of success in their struggles. Unfortunately, that takes finding Mr. Right and making him care about you enough for them to take on the role of guardian for you. I do understand the need for those looking to grow to have a support structure around the, but this one feels like its sending a problematic message instead of a hopeful one.
How I Attended an All Guys Mixer
After agreeing to a mixer, three guys in college wind up becoming close friends with three women who work as drag kings at a host bar. The women, enjoying the malleable mens company, play a drawn out game of flirting, willing to see how long it takes for their prey to realize whats really going on/
This is a really fun and lovable comedy that goes to great lengths to flip the script on romance. The men are easily spooked and oblivious as the women hold all the power in the growth of their relationships. The only down side? I didn't begin watching it until the series was done running. It was one of the highlights of the season it aired! Highly recommended for fans of Ouran High School Host Club.
I Have a Crush at Work
Masugu works in the finance department of a large confectionery company. Yui works in the development department and has a bone to pick with the uptight Masugu. Their dislike of each other is well known by their peers, which makes their secret relationship all the more complex. They begin dating but don't want their relationship to impact their work, so they choose to hide it from everyone, continuing their work rivalry. Yet things are hard to hide when they enjoy each other to the degree they do. Sometimes it's hard to hide your real emotions in public, when caught of guard and as their love deepens so does the gymnastic they have to do to hide it.
I always welcome anime romanced about legit adults in legit adult situations. This is a really cute and enjoyable comedy that can get a little spicy at times, but spicy in a tasteful way. This was such a breath of fresh air among all the rote high school romances that its mundane situations and setting did no damage. The main characters of Masugu and Yui are absolutely lovable and their coworkers are enjoyable as well. This is a nice relaxing and satisfying realistic portrayal of adult love.
I'm Getting Married to the Girl I hate in Class
High school seniors and eternal rivals, Akane and Saito are forced to wed and live together due to their grandparents wanting to recapture their lost youth. As they try to navigate their shared space in amicable ways, they struggle with growing feelings for the other, while working to deny everything and keep it hidden from their peers.
If it wasn't for the likeability of the main characters, this show would have been dropped by episode two. It suffers from everyone else around them being terrible and gimmicky. I do want to reach the source material to see if that is more palatable however.
Love is Indivisible by Twins
Jun is a model student who is close childhood friends with his neighbors, twin girls Rumi and Naori. At the end of middle school Rumi confesses and he accepts her feelings. But after a year she decides it is unfair to her sister, who has likes Jun since they were little and breaks up, forcing them to become a couple. Naori is unwilling to let it be that easy and breaks it off as well, forcing him to make a final decision between which of the two sisters can receive his love. All the while Jun struggles with his unwillingness to actively hurt either of the girls he holds in a special place.
On the surface this should be a terrible story with ecchi moments at every corner. Instead we get a drama full of realistic characters in situations that are not unnatural. The only down side is the less than quality artwork but don't let that distract you from this fantastic drama steeped in the real world.
Makeine: Too Many Losing Heroines
Nukumizu, a friendless introvert light novel fanboy suddenly finds himself involved in his co-eds relationship struggles. One after the other popular girls are being rejected by the boys they like and he tries to use his experience in love via novels to ease their pain...
That's a terrible way of explaining this series but its pretty must the basic concept. But based on that you might picture something featuring an edgy incel being given his opportunity to make the girls swoon for him. You'd be pretty far from the reality. Nukumizu is awkward and confident at the same time, he really has no interest in becoming friends with everyone but feels compelled after he finds himself in the midst of the situations. The girls aren't stereotypical, unnaturally beautiful and mature representations. They are all scrawny and quirky weirdos with complex personalities. This isn't really a romance? It doesn't really deal with Nukumizu pursuing a relationship with anyone and we really don't see anything like that develop. He becomes entangled in helping fellow classmates sort out their messy one sided feelings all while building strange friendships with them. This anime was so good, even if it wasn't a standard definition of a romance.

Medaka Kuroiwa is Impervious to my Charms
Mona is the center of attention where ever she goes. She exist solely to be praised and worshiped by men, women, boys and girls of all ages. When the boy next to her in class, Medaka, refuses to fawn over her, she does everything she can to make him another fan. Medaka, a monk in training, uses every tool at his disposal to clear his mind and soul, avoiding the tempting mistress next to him. His refusal to comply only pushes her further in her efforts for subjugation. Will she be able to overcome his rigorous dedication or will she be swayed instead?
This was a new twist on the standard shonen romance where the narrative character is the girl as she throws herself at the mail lead. Medaka himself is barely the focus. There is a fair amount of casual fanservice that is used tastefully in many instances, but not all. In the end this was a relatively sweet story that had some struggles getting to the potential pay off. Its far better than Strawberry 100% by a lot.
Okitsura: Fell in Love With an Okinawa Girl, But I Just Wish I Know What She's Saying
Teruaki moves to Okinawa from Tokyo for high school and is overly eager to learn about the cultural differences so far from the capital. The first friend he makes in school is a spunky girl named Hina, who has a deep love for her culture and is more and eager to show Teruaki the ways of an Okinawan. This outreach endears her to him and he begins to fall for her. Unfortunately, she uses a lot of local vernacular and he struggles to understand whats shes saying. Fortunately for him, Hina's best friend Kana steps in to work as translator. Thus begins the friendship between all three of them, a friendship where Kana secretly likes Teruaki, who secretly likes Hina who openly loves Okinawa.
This was a really fun and sweet series that spent as much time teaching you about what makes Okinawa special as it does making you love its characters. The character designs are fun, the animation is high quality and the characters lack annoying qualities. My only hope is that we get a second season of this series and some sort of resolution to the love triangle at the core of its plot.
Pseudo Harem
Rin is a first year student and bright star of the schools drama club. She has taken a liking to second year drama club member Eiji, who has taken a liking to her as well. The pair spend their moments together enjoying each others company while flirting innocently. Rin uses her acting chops to assume different personalities, eager to fulfill Eiji's juvenile desires to have a harem of girls fawning over him.
This is a perfect anime. If you want a cute, innocent and endearing story about blossoming love between two characters who enjoy their time together, this is going to deliver the perfect package for you. Every episode becomes increasingly sweet and lovable as they spend more time together, innocently flirting every chance they can get, letting the world slip by beyond them, focused only on each other. Perfection with a chance of diabetes.
Senpai is an Otokonoko
Saki confesses her love for an upperclassman only to find out its really a boy named Makoto who is more comfortable dressing as a girl. Makoto and her develop a friendship, including her into his small circle with his old friend Ryuji. Saki realizes that Ryuji has feelings for Makoto but struggles with them. She had thought she had finally found someone that could be special to her and vice a versa but she realized she is more of a third wheel than anything else.
This is a fantastic story about youth struggling with a world that doesn't appreciate them for who they are. Makoto struggles with everyone's thoughts on his cross dressing and his mothers psychologically abusive responses. Saki struggles with parental abandonment and feelings abnormal when compared to her peers emotional experiences. Ryuji's struggles are internal as he tries to understand his emotions compared to his logic with regards to his life long friend. Its a beautiful story that has many wonderful and sad moments.
Spice and Wolf
Lawrence, a traveling merchant, acquires an unexpected companion in his journeys for profit. Holo has the form of you young woman but in reality she is an long lived wolf god who has decided to leave the land she has long lent her bounty. Her old age has caused her to yearn for the land of her youth, to visit it once more before she is unable to. She convinces Lawrence to be her guide while paying for the service with her supernatural abilities to detect dishonesty and her own shrewdness. Her true identity must be kept secret for fear of the omnipresent 'new' church wanting to kill her as a heretical symbol of a time fading into the past.
This series is more a story revolving around economics than it is romance. But through its course, as the two characters struggle to succeed in their schemes, romance simmers between the man and the wolf, as the wolf is violently jealous and is less than forthcoming about her intentions to be with the young man. While not the most interesting story, myself not being a big fan of historical anime, Holo's character is a breath of fresh air compared to most other female leads. She is confident, powerful and in control of her own destiny. There are very few times in the story where she is a helpless maiden in need of the strong masculine love interest. She has lived for centuries and has faced danger and threats at all corners of the world. Little can cause her to lose control.
Tadaima, Okaeri
Hiromu and his husband Masaki have moved to a newer neighborhood, hoping to escape societal prejudices aimed at their relationship. Masaki is an alpha, the dominant human's who easily fall into roles as leaders in society. Hiromu is an omega, someone who is generally unassertive, meek and able to be impregnated by alphas, regardless of their gender. The two are trying to find a safe and happy environment to raise their young son Hiraki, while working to break through the ceiling of stigma around someones assigned type.
This was my first exposure to the fiction style known as 'omegaverse' that is grounded on the concept of easily dividable humans based on their natural assertiveness of passiveness. Essentially transporting the pseudo science concept of wolf pack orders into erotic fiction as the driver for sub/dom relationships. This series was not explicitly sexual, at least the anime adaptation. It was quite boring and mundane though. To make matters worse, I am not a fan of this style of characterization and over all really disliked the world it built and displayed.
Tokimeki Memorial ~Only Love~
Riku begins his life as a high school student, hoping to remain inconspicuous. That all goes out of the window as his performance in a beginning of the year game, meant to humiliate him, brings him to everyone attention. His innocent success brings a gaggle of girls and competitive males to him as he tries to normalize his life.

Tomo-chan is a Girl
Tomo is the epitome of a tom-boy. When she musters up the courage to confess to her childhood friend, neighbor and fellow karate enthusiast, his reaction is less than ideal. Jun reacts to her as if shes just one of the guys, which is the way hes treated her for the 10+ years they have been best friends. Tomo needs help connecting with her feminine side, convinced once she does Jun will see her as a potential romantic partner.
This series ended up having way more emotion and honesty than I anticipated. What started out as a throw away premise with a limited run gag turned out to be a really endearing story about growing up and coming to terms with the way your relationships change. There is a healthy dose of well timed comedy, realistic mannerisms with the characters and some very grounded introspection. In the end this story wrapped up in a very satisfying manner and is a fine example of quality story telling.
Tsuma Shogakusei Ni Naru
Niijima Takae died in a traffic accident, leaving behind her husband and daughter. Ten years later she finds herself inhabiting the body of a young girl names Marika. She confronts her husband and now adult daughter, convincing them its her. She is determined to use this miracle to change their lives as they have been stuck in a rut of depression since her passing. Will she be able to get them to a point where they can truly live on with out her, the best they can be?
What could have been a slap stick comedy or dangerous perversion turned out to be a really somber story of loss and regret and the struggles of actually getting a second chance to make things right. This was an enjoyable melodrama that proved to be far better than I expected it to be.
Twilight Out Of Focus
Second year students, Mao and Hisashi are room mates at their all boys school. During the beginning of their first year, Mao learned that Hisashi is gay and has a boyfriend. He promised to do everything he could to protect his room mates secret, while Hisashi promises to never pursue Mao as a sexual partner. Mao's feelings begin to change the film club begins to produce their yearly movie and Hisashi is one of the leads, playing a gay man. Mao struggles with his growing feelings and the promise Hisashi has made to him.
This was an interesting yaoi romance that quickly changed focus to other characters that felt annoying, I ended up dropping it half way through as its thinly veiled romance plots began to make way to unimaginative sex scenes and amateur writing. I enjoyed the main couple and liked the progress of their story but lost all interest when it changed focus. The shift appeared to only exist to show yet another 'first time' scene between those characters with little other interest in furthering the story.
Whisper Me A Love Song
One the first day of high school, Himari falls in love with the lead singer of a student band performing in the welcome ceremony. She quickly seeks out the upper classman, Yori and confesses her love for her. Unfortunately for Yori, Himari's love is for the power of her seniors performance, not for the senior herself. Yori, heart broken, is still pleased that the energetic younger girl wants to spend as much time with her as possible. Eventually, Yori confesses to the younger girl her feelings and tries as hard as she can to make ber feelings break through to her.
This was a nice take on the standard high school yuri romance. The initial misunderstanding growing into a burgeoning relationship and then shifting into a interpersonal drama revolving around the girl Yori replaced in the school band. The character designs are questionable but the personalities, motivations and expositions of the small cast is well fleshed out and enjoyable.
Yakuza Fiance: Raise wa Tanin ga Ii
Yoshino finds herself a willing prisoner in a rival yazuka family, under the pretense of marrying the clan boses grandson, Kirishima. Kirishima is dangerous, belittling and abusive but when Yoshino plays the game at his level is disdain for her turns to uncontrollable desire. She wants nothing to do with the violent lose canon, who is too unpredictable to join the ranks of his grandfathers clan. As they find themselves at the center of a dangerous underworld conspiracy Yoshino begins to soften to her captor as she tris to endure it for the time.
There is little actual romance in this series, which has a lot of problems both on the production side and what the characters represent as human beings. But something about Yoshino made me watch it all the way to the end only to find the story on the cusp of being really interesting with no sign of there being more. I'm on the fence about this being worth the time or not...especially since it ends prematurely and took so long to be compelling enough.